Rex Ryan

The Big-Mouthed Football Coach With a Foot Fetish and a Rather Unfortunate Driving Record.

Rex Ryan built his reputation on being the loudest bloke in the NFL, a foul-mouthed, finger-flipping, chest-thumping coach who seemed to think subtlety was something that happened to other people. He talked a big game, promised Super Bowls, publicly insulted opponents and became an internet sensation for reasons that had absolutely nothing to do with football. Now, in November 2026, he’s back in the headlines after being arrested over allegations that he ran over two pedestrians’ feet with his pickup truck and drove away. For a man whose most famous personal controversy already involved feet, the timing is almost too ridiculous to believe.

Ryan is not without sporting achievements. He took the New York Jets to consecutive AFC Championship Games and became a familiar face on ESPN. But between the public outbursts, the infamous foot videos and his latest legal troubles, there’s certainly no shortage of material.

Is a prick because…

  • The Nashville foot incident: On 5 November 2026, Ryan allegedly drove over the feet of two pedestrians crossing Broadway in Nashville. Police say he continued driving, stopped at a traffic light, argued with the pedestrians when they confronted him and then drove away.
  • Driving away instead of taking responsibility: Ryan turned himself in on 11 November after six misdemeanor warrants were issued. The charges include two counts each of leaving the scene of an accident, failing to provide information or render aid, and disobeying a traffic signal. He has not been convicted, and his lawyer says he is cooperating with the investigation.
  • The infamous foot videos: In 2010, videos emerged showing a woman believed to be Ryan’s wife, Michelle, displaying her feet for an off-camera man whose voice sounded like the Jets coach. The footage was published by Deadspin and became a national sporting scandal. Ryan refused to discuss it, describing it as a personal matter.
  • The foot fetish became his entire personality: Rather than allowing the controversy to disappear, Ryan repeatedly brought up his interest in feet on television. He joked about it during NFL discussions, called himself a toe expert and even displayed a framed photograph of feet on his desk while coaching the Buffalo Bills. Eventually, even ordinary football analysis seemed to come with an unnecessary foot-related detour.
  • Flipping the bird to a fan: In 2010, Ryan was caught on camera giving a fan the middle finger during an MMA event in Florida. The Jets fined him $50,000, and he issued an apology.
  • The foul-mouthed outburst: Ryan was fined another $75,000 by the NFL in 2011 after video emerged of him swearing at a fan following a loss to the New England Patriots. The league described him as a repeat offender.
  • The Super Bowl promises: Ryan regularly made grand predictions about his teams’ prospects, including confidently predicting a Jets Super Bowl victory. Despite reaching the AFC Championship twice, he never delivered the trophy and never returned to the playoffs with the Jets after the 2010 season.
  • The big mouth: Ryan developed a reputation for personal insults and confrontational comments about opposing teams and players. His aggressive personality was part of his public appeal, but it also regularly attracted unwanted attention and disciplinary action.
  • The Buffalo Bills failure: After leaving the Jets, Ryan became head coach of the Buffalo Bills in 2015. He failed to take them to the playoffs and was fired before the end of the 2016 season, leaving with a disappointing record after all the big talk.

Is not a prick because…

  • He was a genuinely successful defensive coach: Ryan was an important part of the Baltimore Ravens’ coaching staff and helped develop one of the NFL’s strongest defensive units. His work earned him widespread respect around the league.
  • He took the Jets further than most expected: Ryan led the New York Jets to consecutive AFC Championship Games in 2009 and 2010. The franchise has struggled to reproduce that success since.
  • Players liked him: Despite his confrontational public persona, Ryan was popular with many of his players, who appreciated his loyalty, enthusiasm and willingness to defend them.
  • He knows football: His television career with ESPN has demonstrated that he can analyse the game, explain defensive strategy and provide entertaining commentary. There is a reason he has remained a regular presence on NFL coverage.

Rex Ryan spent years making himself famous for being loud, aggressive and completely unapologetic. His coaching career had genuine highs, but his mouth and appetite for attention repeatedly landed him in trouble. The foot fetish itself is nobody else’s business, but allegedly running over pedestrians’ feet and driving away is a rather different matter. For a man who has spent 16 years being associated with toes, he could hardly have picked a more unfortunate way to return to the headlines.

prickmeter

100% say yes (1 Yes / 0 No)

Cast your vote. One vote per visitor and item; you can change your vote.